Satya Nadella thinks the business model behind much of the modern web has an expiration date, and he’s not shy about saying who should worry. Speaking at the New York Times DealBook Summit, the Microsoft CEO predicted that AI agents will reshuffle who pays whom for traffic and transactions.
His core argument is simple. Today’s aggregators built their economics around what he called the “human web.” Get people to look at a page, sell ads against those views. Agents don’t look at anything. They query, compare and buy. So Nadella suggested that ad revenue tied to eyeballs may shrink to something closer to cost-per-click, or even purely transactional models. “If you don’t accept the agent, somebody else will,” he said.
He compared it to the move from web portals like Yahoo to search engines like Google. That shift didn’t just change where people started their browsing. It moved money, and it created a new set of winners while older gatekeepers faded. It’s a fair analogy, though the stakes may be bigger this time because the user is no longer a person at all.
The sharpest part of the conversation was about Amazon, which blocks AI agents from browsing its catalog and buying on behalf of users. Nadella’s view is that protecting an existing model can backfire. If Amazon keeps agents out, a rival such as Shopify could let them in and pick up the business. That’s the logic of a platform shift: the company that is easiest for the new interface to work with tends to collect the traffic.
Of course, Nadella isn’t a neutral observer. Microsoft sells Copilot, runs Azure, and has a big stake in OpenAI, so a web friendly to agents is a web friendly to Microsoft’s products. Amazon also has its own reasons to hold back. It sells ads on its marketplace, it has its own assistant, and it doesn’t want a third-party agent sitting between it and its customers. Google faces a similar tension, since its search ad business depends on humans clicking results.
Still, the direction of travel is hard to dispute. OpenAI, Google, Perplexity and others are all pushing agents that shop and book on users’ behalf, and publishers are already seeing less referral traffic from AI-driven search. Whether platforms charge agents, partner with them or wall them off is the open question.
Nadella’s closing point is the one worth remembering. “If you’re in love with a particular business model, you have to kind of scramble.” For retailers, publishers and ad-funded platforms, that’s less a prediction than a planning prompt.



